Rookie Football Cards

To see a large picture of any card (or stamp, sticker, etc.) in the Gallery, click on the small picture or the title.

Picture Set # Card Title/Players Pro Team Position College Honors Notes Est. Retail Value (?) Grades available at nearmintcards.com
1960 Fleer Dan McGrew 1960 Fleer 3 Dan McGrew Buffalo Bills center Purdue Rookie card

McGrew played one season for the Bills, 1960. His 1960 Fleer card pictures him in his Purdue uniform.

ex $4

nm $18

1960 Fleer Bob White 1960 Fleer 4 Bob White Houston Oilers fullback Ohio State Rookie card

ex $5

nm $19

1960 Fleer Dick Jamieson 1960 Fleer 5 Dick Jamieson Dallas Texans quarterback Bradley Rookie card

ex $5

nm $16

1960 Fleer Sid Gillman 1960 Fleer 7 Sid Gillman Los Angeles Chargers coach Ohio State Chargers Hall of Fame 1985, College Hall of Fame 1989, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1983 Rookie card

ex $10

nm $30

PSA 8, vg-ex
1960 Fleer Ben Preston 1960 Fleer 8 Ben Preston Los Angeles Chargers end Auburn Rookie card

ex $2

nm $7

PSA 8
1960 Fleer Elbert Dubenion 1960 Fleer 17 Elbert Dubenion Buffalo Bills halfback Bluffton Bills Wall of Fame 1993 Rookie card

ex $5

nm $14

nm oc
1960 Fleer Bill Atkins 1960 Fleer 24 Bill Atkins Buffalo Bills defensive back Auburn Rookie card

ex $3

nm $9

1960 Fleer Tony Teresa 1960 Fleer 27 Tony Teresa Oakland Raiders halfback San Jose State Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

1960 Fleer Joe Amstutz 1960 Fleer 28 Joe Amstutz Los Angeles Chargers center Indiana Rookie card

Amstutz never played a regular season game in the AFL. He did play for the Cleveland Browns in 1957, however.

ex $2

nm $6

nm
1960 Fleer Jim Baldwin 1960 Fleer 30 Jim Baldwin New York Titans center McMurry Rookie card

Baldwin is pictured in his McMurry College uniform. He never played in the regular season in the AFL.

ex $3

nm $8

1960 Fleer Ken Adamson 1960 Fleer 33 Ken Adamson Denver Broncos guard Notre Dame Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

1960 Fleer Jack Lee 1960 Fleer 38 Jack Lee Houston Oilers quarterback Cincinnati Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

1960 Fleer Ray Moss 1960 Fleer 44 Ray Moss Buffalo Bills linebacker Tennessee Rookie card

Moss's father, Ray Moss Sr., played major league baseball for the Brooklyn Robins and Boston Braves.

ex $2

nm $5

PSA 8.5, nm
1960 Fleer Tony Banfield 1960 Fleer 45 Tony Banfield Houston Oilers defensive back Oklahoma State Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

1960 Fleer Bill Brown 1960 Fleer 49 Bill Brown Boston Patriots center Syracuse Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

nm
1960 Fleer Billy Kinard 1960 Fleer 51 Billy Kinard Buffalo Bills halfback Mississippi Rookie card

Kinard is the younger brother of Pro Football Hall of Famer Bruiser Kinard. He was the head coach at Mississippi from 1971 to 1973. Another brother, George, played for the NFL's Brooklyn Dodgers and AAFC's New York Yankees.

ex $3

nm $8

1960 Fleer Frank Bernardi 1960 Fleer 54 Frank Bernardi Denver Broncos halfback Colorado Rookie card

Bernardi was inducted into the University of Colorado Athletic Hall of Fame in 2012. The image on this card pictures him in his Colorado uniform, though he was playing in the NFL by 1955.

ex $3

nm $8

1960 Fleer Lou Saban 1960 Fleer 55 Lou Saban Boston Patriots coach Indiana Rookie card

ex $4

nm $12

nm
1960 Fleer Sherrill Headrick 1960 Fleer 59 Sherrill Headrick Dallas Texans linebacker TCU Chiefs Hall of Fame 1993 Rookie card

ex $4

nm $12

1960 Fleer Bob McNamara 1960 Fleer 63 Bob McNamara Boston Patriots halfback Minnesota Rookie card

This card shows McNamara with the Boston Patriots, but he played for the Denver Broncos in 1960.

ex $2

nm $6

1960 Fleer Billy Cannon 1960 Fleer 66 Billy Cannon Houston Oilers halfback LSU College Hall of Fame 2008, Heisman Trophy 1959 Rookie card

The Los Angeles Rams chose Cannon with the first overall pick in the 1960 NFL draft. He opted to play in the AFL instead.

ex $10

nm $30

1960 Fleer Sam McCord 1960 Fleer 67 Sam McCord Oakland Raiders quarterback Texas A and M - Commerce Rookie card

McCord was inducted into the Lone Star Conference Hall of Honor in 2006. He never played a regular season game in the AFL or NFL.

ex $2

nm $6

nm+
1960 Fleer Mike Simmons 1960 Fleer 68 Mike Simmons New York Titans end Auburn Rookie card

ex $2

nm $4

PSA 9, SGC 88, nm
1960 Fleer Gerhard Schwedes 1960 Fleer 71 Gerhard Schwedes Boston Patriots halfback Syracuse Rookie card

Schwedes played two seasons for the AFL's Boston Patriots and New York Titans. His son, Scott, was a wide receiver for the Miami Dolphins and San Diego Chargers.

ex $2

nm $5

1960 Fleer Abner Haynes 1960 Fleer 73 Abner Haynes Dallas Texans halfback North Texas Chiefs Hall of Fame 1991 Rookie card

ex $5

nm $19

1960 Fleer Paul Lowe 1960 Fleer 76 Paul Lowe Los Angeles Chargers halfback Oregon State Chargers Hall of Fame 1979 Rookie card

ex $6

nm $37

vg
1960 Fleer Chris Burford 1960 Fleer 81 Chris Burford Dallas Texans end Stanford Chiefs Hall of Fame 1975, College Hall of Fame 1995 Rookie card

ex $6

nm $30

1960 Fleer Jim Woodard 1960 Fleer 84 Jim Woodard Oakland Raiders tackle Lamar State Rookie card

ex $9

nm $67

PSA 9 oc, vg-ex
1960 Fleer Tom Rychlec 1960 Fleer 85 Tom Rychlec Buffalo Bills end American International Rookie card

Rychlec played one season for the NFL's Detroit Lions before joining the Bills in 1960.

ex $2

nm $6

PSA 8, nm+
1960 Fleer Jerry Cornelison 1960 Fleer 87 Jerry Cornelison Dallas Texans guard SMU Rookie card

ex $3

nm $8

1960 Fleer Sam DeLuca 1960 Fleer 89 Sam DeLuca Los Angeles Chargers tackle, guard South Carolina Rookie card

ex $2

nm $7

PSA 8
1960 Fleer Rommie Loudd 1960 Fleer 90 Rommie Loudd Los Angeles Chargers linebacker UCLA, Los Angeles Valley College Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

PSA 8, nm
1960 Fleer Richie Lucas 1960 Fleer 96 Richie Lucas Buffalo Bills quarterback, halfback Penn State College Hall of Fame 1986 Rookie card

ex $3

nm $7

vg
1960 Fleer Mel Branch 1960 Fleer 100 Mel Branch Dallas Texans defensive end LSU Rookie card

ex $2

nm $7

1960 Fleer Charlie Flowers 1960 Fleer 102 Charlie Flowers Los Angeles Chargers fullback Mississippi College Hall of Fame 1997 Rookie card

ex $3

nm $7

exmt
1960 Fleer Bob Dee 1960 Fleer 111 Bob Dee Boston Patriots defensive end Holy Cross Patriots Hall of Fame 1993 Rookie card

ex $3

nm $8

1960 Fleer Stan Flowers 1960 Fleer 115 Stan Flowers Boston Patriots halfback Georgia Tech Rookie card

ex $2

nm $7

nm
1960 Fleer Hank Stram 1960 Fleer 116 Hank Stram Dallas Texans coach Purdue Chiefs Hall of Fame 1987, Pro Football Hall of Fame 2003 Rookie card

Stram was inducted into the National Polish-American Sports Hall of Fame in 1985.

ex $10

nm $30

1960 Fleer Ron Mix 1960 Fleer 118 Ron Mix Los Angeles Chargers tackle USC Chargers Hall of Fame 1978, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1979 Rookie card

ex $10

nm $30

1960 Fleer Jack Kemp 1960 Fleer 124 Jack Kemp Los Angeles Chargers quarterback Occidental Bills Wall of Fame 1984 Rookie card

ex $20

nm $60

1960 Fleer Paul Maguire 1960 Fleer 128 Paul Maguire Los Angeles Chargers end Citadel Rookie card

ex $5

nm $12

nm
1960 Fleer Ron Burton 1960 Fleer 130 Ron Burton Boston Patriots halfback Northwestern College Hall of Fame 1990 Rookie card

ex $2

nm $7

1960 Fleer Ron Beagle 1960 Fleer 132 Ron Beagle Oakland Raiders end Navy College Hall of Fame 1986 Rookie card

Beagle placed seventh in voting for the 1955 Heisman Trophy. See my page of football cards of Heisman candidates.

ex $2

nm $6

vg
1960 Topps Bill Pellington 1960 Topps 8 Bill Pellington Baltimore Colts linebacker Rutgers Rookie card

ex $2

nm $9

1960 Topps John Sample 1960 Topps 9 John Sample Baltimore Colts defensive back Maryland Eastern Shore Rookie card

ex $2

nm $11

PSA 5, exmt
1960 Topps Erich Barnes 1960 Topps 19 Erich Barnes Chicago Bears defensive back Purdue Rookie card

ex $2

nm $8

nm
1960 Topps Jim Gibbons 1960 Topps 44 Jim Gibbons Detroit Lions end Iowa Rookie card

ex $2

nm $8

1960 Topps Darris McCord 1960 Topps 45 Darris McCord Detroit Lions defensive end Tennessee Rookie card

McCord played 13 seasons in the NFL, all with the Lions.

ex $2

nm $10

ex
1960 Topps Gil Mains 1960 Topps 49 Gil Mains Detroit Lions defensive tackle Murray State Rookie card

ex $2

nm $9

PSA 8, exmt
1960 Topps Forrest Gregg 1960 Topps 56 Forrest Gregg Green Bay Packers offensive tackle SMU Packers Hall of Fame 1977, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1977 Rookie card, error card

Gregg's first name is misspelled "Forest" on both the front and back of this card.

ex $10

nm $30

nm oc

Sponsored Links

Copyright 2003-2014, Nearmint's Vintage Football Cards