Pro Football Hall Of Fame + Rookie Football Cards

To see a large picture of any card (or stamp, sticker, etc.) in the Gallery, click on the small picture or the title.

Picture Set # Card Title/Players Pro Team Position College Honors Notes Est. Retail Value (?) Grades available at nearmintcards.com
1956 Topps Lenny Moore 1956 Topps 60 Lenny Moore Baltimore Colts halfback Penn State Pro Football Hall of Fame 1975 Rookie card

Moore was named the 1956 UPI NFL Rookie of the Year.

ex $16

nm $30

PSA 6
1956 Topps Stan Jones 1956 Topps 71 Stan Jones Chicago Bears guard Maryland College Hall of Fame 2000, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1991 Rookie card

ex $12

nm $15

exmt
1957 Topps Jack Butler 1957 Topps 15 Jack Butler Pittsburgh Steelers defensive back St. Bonaventure Pro Football Hall of Fame 2012 Rookie card

ex $25

nm $75

PSA 7, PSA 6 st, PSA 5, ex
1957 Topps Dick Lane 1957 Topps 85 Dick Lane Chicago Cardinals defensive back Scottsbluff Junior College Cardinals Ring of Honor 2006, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1974 Rookie card

ex $50

nm $150

exmt
1957 Topps Raymond Berry 1957 Topps 94 Raymond Berry Baltimore Colts end SMU Pro Football Hall of Fame 1973 Rookie card

ex $75

nm $225

1957 Topps Bart Starr 1957 Topps 119 Bart Starr Green Bay Packers quarterback Alabama Packers Hall of Fame 1977, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1977 Rookie card

The Packers chose Starr in the 17th round of the 1956 NFL draft. He was the 200th player taken in the draft.

ex $300

nm $750

PSA 3
1957 Topps Tommy McDonald 1957 Topps 124 Tommy McDonald Philadelphia Eagles end, halfback Oklahoma College Hall of Fame 1985, Eagles Honor Roll 1988, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1998 Rookie card

ex $30

nm $90

PSA 6
1957 Topps John Unitas 1957 Topps 138 John Unitas Baltimore Colts quarterback Louisville Pro Football Hall of Fame 1979 Rookie card

ex $225

nm $550

PSA 3
1957 Topps Paul Hornung 1957 Topps 151 Paul Hornung Green Bay Packers halfback Notre Dame College Hall of Fame 1985, Heisman Trophy 1956, Packers Hall of Fame 1975, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1986 Rookie card

The Packers chose Hornung with the first overall pick in the 1957 NFL draft.

ex $175

nm $450

PSA 6
1958 Topps Jim Brown 1958 Topps 62 Jim Brown Cleveland Browns fullback Syracuse Browns Ring of Honor 2010, College Hall of Fame 1995, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1971 Rookie card

ex $250

nm $700

PSA 8 mc, PSA 5, PSA 1
1958 Topps Sonny Jurgensen 1958 Topps 90 Sonny Jurgensen Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Duke Eagles Honor Roll 1987, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1983, Redskins Ring of Fame 2000 Rookie card

ex $30

nm $100

PSA 8 oc, PSA 5
1959 Topps Sam Huff 1959 Topps 51 Sam Huff New York Giants linebacker West Virginia College Hall of Fame 1980, Giants Ring of Honor 2010, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1982, Redskins Ring of Fame 2000 Rookie card

ex $7

nm $30

1959 Topps Jim Parker 1959 Topps 132 Jim Parker Baltimore Colts guard, tackle Ohio State College Hall of Fame 1974, Outland Trophy 1956, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1973 Rookie card

ex $18

nm $35

vg-ex
1959 Topps Bobby Mitchell 1959 Topps 140 Bobby Mitchell Cleveland Browns halfback Illinois Browns Ring of Honor 2010, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1983, Redskins Ring of Fame 2000 Rookie card

ex $15

nm $30

good
1959 Topps Jim Taylor 1959 Topps 155 Jim Taylor Green Bay Packers fullback LSU Packers Hall of Fame 1975, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1976 Rookie card, error card

The player pictured on this card is Jim Taylor of the Cardinals, not Jim Taylor of the Packers. See my Mistaken Identities page for details.

ex $10

nm $30

PSA 7, PSA 6, exmt
1960 Fleer Sid Gillman 1960 Fleer 7 Sid Gillman Los Angeles Chargers coach Ohio State Chargers Hall of Fame 1985, College Hall of Fame 1989, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1983 Rookie card

ex $10

nm $30

vg-ex
1960 Fleer Hank Stram 1960 Fleer 116 Hank Stram Dallas Texans coach Purdue Chiefs Hall of Fame 1987, Pro Football Hall of Fame 2003 Rookie card

Stram was inducted into the National Polish-American Sports Hall of Fame in 1985.

ex $10

nm $30

exmt
1960 Fleer Ron Mix 1960 Fleer 118 Ron Mix Los Angeles Chargers tackle USC Chargers Hall of Fame 1978, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1979 Rookie card

ex $10

nm $30

1960 Topps Forrest Gregg 1960 Topps 56 Forrest Gregg Green Bay Packers offensive tackle SMU Packers Hall of Fame 1977, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1977 Rookie card, error card

Gregg's first name is misspelled "Forest" on both the front and back of this card.

ex $10

nm $30

nm oc
1961 Fleer Jim Otto 1961 Fleer 197 Jim Otto Oakland Raiders center Miami Florida Pro Football Hall of Fame 1980 Rookie card

ex $20

nm $50

1961 Fleer Don Maynard 1961 Fleer 215 Don Maynard New York Titans end Texas-El Paso Jets Ring of Honor 2010, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1987 Rookie card

ex $20

nm $50

1961 Topps Henry Jordan 1961 Topps 45 Henry Jordan Green Bay Packers tackle Virginia Packers Hall of Fame 1975, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1995 Rookie card

ex $15

nm $35

1961 Topps Don Maynard 1961 Topps 150 Don Maynard New York Titans end Texas-El Paso Jets Ring of Honor 2010, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1987 Rookie card

ex $15

nm $35

SGC 88, PSA 7
1961 Topps Jim Otto 1961 Topps 182 Jim Otto Oakland Raiders center Miami Florida Pro Football Hall of Fame 1980 Rookie card

ex $15

nm $35

1962 Fleer Billy Shaw 1962 Fleer 16 Billy Shaw Buffalo Bills guard Georgia Tech Bills Wall of Fame 1988, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1999 Rookie card

ex $40

nm $100

1962 Topps Mike Ditka 1962 Topps 17 Mike Ditka Chicago Bears tight end Pittsburgh Pro Football Hall of Fame 1988 Rookie card, short print

ex $140

nm $300

1962 Topps Fran Tarkenton 1962 Topps 90 Fran Tarkenton Minnesota Vikings quarterback Georgia College Hall of Fame 1987, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1986, Vikings Ring of Honor 1998 Rookie card

ex $85

nm $250

fair
1963 Fleer Nick Buoniconti 1963 Fleer 10 Nick Buoniconti Boston Patriots linebacker Notre Dame Dolphins Honor Roll 1991, Patriots Hall of Fame 1992, Pro Football Hall of Fame 2001 Rookie card

ex $50

nm $125

1963 Fleer Len Dawson 1963 Fleer 47 Len Dawson Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Purdue Chiefs Hall of Fame 1979, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1987 Rookie card

ex $100

nm $250

PSA 8
1963 Fleer Lance Alworth 1963 Fleer 72 Lance Alworth San Diego Chargers end Arkansas Chargers Hall of Fame 1977, College Hall of Fame 1984, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1978 Rookie card

ex $100

nm $250

1963 Topps Deacon Jones 1963 Topps 44 Deacon Jones Los Angeles Rams defensive end Mississippi Vocational Pro Football Hall of Fame 1980 Rookie card

The Rams drafted Jones in the 14th round of the 1961 NFL draft.

ex $20

nm $50

exmt
1963 Topps Bob Lilly 1963 Topps 82 Bob Lilly Dallas Cowboys end TCU College Hall of Fame 1981, Cowboys Ring of Honor 1975, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1980 Rookie card, short print

ex $65

nm $160

1963 Topps Willie Wood 1963 Topps 95 Willie Wood Green Bay Packers defensive back USC Packers Hall of Fame 1977, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1989 Rookie card

ex $20

nm $50

PSA 8, nm
1963 Topps Ray Nitschke 1963 Topps 96 Ray Nitschke Green Bay Packers linebacker Illinois Packers Hall of Fame 1978, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1978 Rookie card

ex $65

nm $160

PSA 7
1963 Topps Larry Wilson 1963 Topps 155 Larry Wilson St. Louis Cardinals defensive back Utah Cardinals Ring of Honor 2006, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1978 Rookie card

ex $12

nm $30

PSA 7, exmt
1964 Philadelphia John Mackey 1964 Philadelphia 3 John Mackey Baltimore Colts tight end Syracuse Pro Football Hall of Fame 1992 Rookie card

ex $20

nm $60

1964 Philadelphia Herb Adderley 1964 Philadelphia 71 Herb Adderley Green Bay Packers defensive back Michigan State Packers Hall of Fame 1981, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1980 Rookie card, error card

Name misspelled "Adderly."

ex $10

nm $30

ex
1964 Philadelphia Willie Davis 1964 Philadelphia 72 Willie Davis Green Bay Packers defensive end Grambling Packers Hall of Fame 1975, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1981 Rookie card

ex $10

nm $30

1964 Philadelphia Merlin Olsen 1964 Philadelphia 91 Merlin Olsen Los Angeles Rams tackle Utah State College Hall of Fame 1980, Outland Trophy 1961, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1982 Rookie card

ex $10

nm $30

PSA 9, PSA 7
1964 Philadelphia Jim Johnson 1964 Philadelphia 161 Jim Johnson San Francisco 49ers defensive back UCLA 49ers Hall of Fame 2009, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1994 Rookie card

ex $15

nm $45

1964 Topps Bobby Bell 1964 Topps 90 Bobby Bell Kansas City Chiefs linebacker, defensive end Minnesota Chiefs Hall of Fame 1980, College Hall of Fame 1991, Outland Trophy 1962, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1983 Rookie card

ex $12

nm $40

PSA 5.5
1964 Topps Buck Buchanan 1964 Topps 92 Buck Buchanan Kansas City Chiefs defensive tackle Grambling Chiefs Hall of Fame 1981, College Hall of Fame 1996, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1990 Rookie card

ex $12

nm $40

PSA 8, vg-ex
1965 Philadelphia Paul Warfield 1965 Philadelphia 41 Paul Warfield Cleveland Browns wide receiver Ohio State Browns Ring of Honor 2010, Dolphins Honor Roll 1990, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1983 Rookie card

ex $20

nm $45

1965 Philadelphia Mel Renfro 1965 Philadelphia 53 Mel Renfro Dallas Cowboys defensive back Oregon College Hall of Fame 1986, Cowboys Ring of Honor 1977, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1996 Rookie card

ex $20

nm $60

PSA 7
1965 Philadelphia Dick LeBeau 1965 Philadelphia 64 Dick LeBeau Detroit Lions defensive back Ohio State Pro Football Hall of Fame 2010 Rookie card

ex $25

nm $65

1965 Philadelphia Carl Eller 1965 Philadelphia 105 Carl Eller Minnesota Vikings defensive end Minnesota College Hall of Fame 2006, Pro Football Hall of Fame 2004, Vikings Ring of Honor 2002 Rookie card

ex $20

nm $45

vg-ex
1965 Philadelphia Paul Krause 1965 Philadelphia 189 Paul Krause Washington Redskins defensive back Iowa Pro Football Hall of Fame 1998, Vikings Ring of Honor 1998 Rookie card

ex $20

nm $50

1965 Philadelphia Charley Taylor 1965 Philadelphia 195 Charley Taylor Washington Redskins wide receiver Arizona State Pro Football Hall of Fame 1984, Redskins Ring of Fame 2000 Rookie card

ex $20

nm $55

PSA 6
1965 Topps Willie Brown 1965 Topps 46 Willie Brown Denver Broncos defensive back Grambling Pro Football Hall of Fame 1984 Rookie card

ex $50

nm $125

1965 Topps Joe Namath 1965 Topps 122 Joe Namath New York Jets quarterback Alabama Jets Ring of Honor 2010, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1985 Rookie card

ex $700

nm $1750


Sponsored Links

Copyright 2003-2014, Nearmint's Vintage Football Cards