Cookie Gilchrist Football Cards
| Image | Set | # | Card Title/Players | Pro Team | Position | College | Honors | Notes | Grades available at Nearmint Sports Cards |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
1958 Topps CFL | 28 | Cookie Gilchrist | Saskatchewan Roughriders | fullback | Bills Wall of Fame 2017 | Gilchrist played in the CFL from 1956 to 1961, and in the AFL from 1962 to 1967. | ||
|
1961 Topps CFL | 106 | Cookie Gilchrist | Toronto Argonauts | fullback | Bills Wall of Fame 2017 | Gilchrist's full name was Carlton Chester Gilchrist. | ||
|
1962 Post CFL | 39 | Cookie Gilchrist | Toronto Argonauts | fullback | Bills Wall of Fame 2017 | |||
|
1962 Topps CFL | 134 | Cookie Gilchrist | Toronto Argonauts | fullback | Bills Wall of Fame 2017 | Gilchrist did not play for Toronto in 1962. He played for the AFL's Buffalo Bills, and he led the AFL in rushing. | ||
|
1963 Fleer | 23 | Cookie Gilchrist | Buffalo Bills | fullback | Bills Wall of Fame 2017 | Rookie card | ||
|
1964 Topps | 29 | Cookie Gilchrist | Buffalo Bills | fullback | Bills Wall of Fame 2017 | Short print Gilchrist led the American Football League in rushing for the second time in 1964. |
||
| 1965 Topps | 51 | Cookie Gilchrist | Denver Broncos | fullback | Bills Wall of Fame 2017 | Gilchrist rushed for 6 touchdowns in 1965, tying Curtis McClinton, Wray Carlton, and Paul Lowe for most in the AFL. | PSA 8 | ||
|
1966 Topps | 32 | Cookie Gilchrist | Denver Broncos | fullback | Bills Wall of Fame 2017 | This card shows Gilchrist with the Broncos (and wearing a Buffalo Bills jersey), but he played for the Miami Dolphins in 1966. | ||
|
1967 Topps | 74 | Cookie Gilchrist | Miami Dolphins | fullback | Bills Wall of Fame 2017 | This card shows Gilchrist with the Dolphins (and wearing a Buffalo Bills jersey), but he played for the Denver Broncos in 1967. The Dolphins traded him to the Broncos in June. |







