Buffalo Bills Football Cards

To see a large picture of any card (or stamp, sticker, etc.) in the Gallery, click on the small picture or the title.

Picture Set # Card Title/Players Pro Team Position College Honors Notes Est. Retail Value (?) Grades available at nearmintcards.com
1961 Topps Flocked Stickers Buffalo Bills 1961 Topps Flocked Stickers 39M Buffalo Bills Buffalo Bills
1962 Fleer Art Baker 1962 Fleer 12 Art Baker Buffalo Bills fullback Syracuse

ex $3

nm $8

PSA 8, nm oc
1962 Fleer Chuck Green 1962 Fleer 13 Chuck Green Buffalo Bills quarterback Tennessee-Chatanooga

ex $3

nm $10

1962 Fleer Elbert Dubenion 1962 Fleer 14 Elbert Dubenion Buffalo Bills halfback Bluffton Bills Wall of Fame 1993

ex $6

nm $20

1962 Fleer Tom Rychlec 1962 Fleer 15 Tom Rychlec Buffalo Bills end American International

ex $3

nm $14

1962 Fleer Billy Shaw 1962 Fleer 16 Billy Shaw Buffalo Bills guard Georgia Tech Bills Wall of Fame 1988, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1999 Rookie card

ex $40

nm $100

1962 Fleer Ken Rice 1962 Fleer 17 Ken Rice Buffalo Bills tackle Auburn

ex $3

nm $6

PSA 8
1962 Fleer Bill Atkins 1962 Fleer 18 Bill Atkins Buffalo Bills defensive back Auburn

ex $3

nm $8

PSA 7, nm-mt oc
1962 Fleer Richie Lucas 1962 Fleer 19 Richie Lucas Buffalo Bills quarterback, halfback Penn State College Hall of Fame 1986

ex $3

nm $7

1962 Fleer Archie Matsos 1962 Fleer 20 Archie Matsos Buffalo Bills linebacker Michigan State

ex $3

nm $8

PSA 7, nm-mt oc
1962 Fleer Laverne Torczon 1962 Fleer 21 Laverne Torczon Buffalo Bills defensive end Nebraska Rookie card

ex $3

nm $8

PSA 7
1962 Fleer Warren Rabb 1962 Fleer 22 Warren Rabb Buffalo Bills quarterback LSU Error card

Rabb's name is misspelled "Raab."

ex $3

nm $8

PSA 8
1963 Fleer Cookie Gilchrist 1963 Fleer 23 Cookie Gilchrist Buffalo Bills fullback Rookie card

ex $12

nm $30

1963 Fleer Jack Kemp 1963 Fleer 24 Jack Kemp Buffalo Bills quarterback Occidental Bills Wall of Fame 1984

ex $20

nm $50

PSA 8
1963 Fleer Wray Carlton 1963 Fleer 25 Wray Carlton Buffalo Bills fullback Duke

ex $4

nm $13

1963 Fleer Elbert Dubenion 1963 Fleer 26 Elbert Dubenion Buffalo Bills halfback Bluffton Bills Wall of Fame 1993

ex $6

nm $15

1963 Fleer Ernie Warlick 1963 Fleer 27 Ernie Warlick Buffalo Bills tight end North Carolina College Rookie card

ex $4

nm $8

1963 Fleer Billy Shaw 1963 Fleer 28 Billy Shaw Buffalo Bills guard Georgia Tech Bills Wall of Fame 1988, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1999 Shaw is the only member of the Pro Football Hall of Fame who never played in the NFL. He played his entire career in the AFL, before it merged with the NFL.

ex $12

nm $30

1963 Fleer Ken Rice 1963 Fleer 29 Ken Rice Buffalo Bills tackle Auburn

ex $4

nm $8

1963 Fleer Booker Edgerson 1963 Fleer 30 Booker Edgerson Buffalo Bills defensive back Western Illinois Bills Wall of Fame 2010 Rookie card

ex $5

nm $13

1963 Fleer Ray Abruzzese 1963 Fleer 31 Ray Abruzzese Buffalo Bills defensive back Alabama Rookie card, error card

Abruzzese's name is misspelled "Abbruzzese" on this card.

ex $4

nm $7

1963 Fleer Mike Stratton 1963 Fleer 32 Mike Stratton Buffalo Bills linebacker Tennessee Bills Wall of Fame 1994 Rookie card

ex $5

nm $12

1963 Fleer Tom Sestak 1963 Fleer 33 Tom Sestak Buffalo Bills defensive tackle McNeese State, Baylor Bills Wall of Fame 1987 Rookie card

ex $5

nm $13

1964 Topps Ray Abruzzese 1964 Topps 22 Ray Abruzzese Buffalo Bills defensive back Alabama Error card

The player pictured on this card is Ed Rutkowski, not Ray Abruzzese. See my Mistaken Identities page for other football cards that picture the wrong player.

ex $3

nm $7

nm
1964 Topps Stew Barber 1964 Topps 23 Stew Barber Buffalo Bills linebacker Penn State Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

1964 Topps Dave Behrman 1964 Topps 24 Dave Behrman Buffalo Bills center Michigan State Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

1964 Topps Al Bemiller 1964 Topps 25 Al Bemiller Buffalo Bills center Syracuse Rookie card

ex $3

nm $7

1964 Topps Elbert Dubenion 1964 Topps 26 Elbert Dubenion Buffalo Bills halfback Bluffton Bills Wall of Fame 1993 Short print

ex $3

nm $10

1964 Topps Jim Dunaway 1964 Topps 27 Jim Dunaway Buffalo Bills defensive tackle Mississippi Rookie card, short print

ex $3

nm $11

1964 Topps Booker Edgerson 1964 Topps 28 Booker Edgerson Buffalo Bills defensive back Western Illinois Bills Wall of Fame 2010 Short print

ex $3

nm $7

1964 Topps Cookie Gilchrist 1964 Topps 29 Cookie Gilchrist Buffalo Bills fullback Short print

Gilchrist led the American Football League in rushing for the second time in 1964.

ex $8

nm $20

1964 Topps Jack Kemp 1964 Topps 30 Jack Kemp Buffalo Bills quarterback Occidental Bills Wall of Fame 1984 Short print

ex $12

nm $35

1964 Topps Daryle Lamonica 1964 Topps 31 Daryle Lamonica Buffalo Bills quarterback Notre Dame Rookie card

ex $12

nm $35

1964 Topps Bill Miller 1964 Topps 32 Bill Miller Buffalo Bills end Miami Florida

ex $3

nm $6

1964 Topps Herb Paterra 1964 Topps 33 Herb Paterra Buffalo Bills linebacker Michigan State Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

nm
1964 Topps Ken Rice 1964 Topps 34 Ken Rice Buffalo Bills tackle Auburn Short print

ex $3

nm $8

1964 Topps Ed Rutkowski 1964 Topps 35 Ed Rutkowski Buffalo Bills defensive back Notre Dame Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

PSA 8
1964 Topps George Saimes 1964 Topps 36 George Saimes Buffalo Bills defensive back Michigan State Bills Wall of Fame 2000 Rookie card

ex $3

nm $6

1964 Topps Tom Sestak 1964 Topps 37 Tom Sestak Buffalo Bills defensive tackle McNeese State, Baylor Bills Wall of Fame 1987

ex $2

nm $5

1964 Topps Billy Shaw 1964 Topps 38 Billy Shaw Buffalo Bills guard Georgia Tech Bills Wall of Fame 1988, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1999 Short print

ex $8

nm $20

1964 Topps Mike Stratton 1964 Topps 39 Mike Stratton Buffalo Bills linebacker Tennessee Bills Wall of Fame 1994

ex $3

nm $7

nm
1964 Topps Gene Sykes 1964 Topps 40 Gene Sykes Buffalo Bills defensive back LSU Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

nm
1964 Topps John Tracey 1964 Topps 41 John Tracey Buffalo Bills linebacker Texas A and M Rookie card, short print

ex $3

nm $8

exmt
1964 Topps Sid Youngelman 1964 Topps 42 Sid Youngelman Buffalo Bills defensive tackle Alabama Short print

ex $3

nm $7

exmt
1964 Topps Buffalo Bills Team 1964 Topps 43 Buffalo Bills Team Buffalo Bills

ex $3

nm $10

1965 Topps Stew Barber 1965 Topps 23 Stew Barber Buffalo Bills linebacker Penn State

ex $8

nm $40

1965 Topps Glenn Bass 1965 Topps 24 Glenn Bass Buffalo Bills end East Carolina Rookie card

ex $5

nm $18

1965 Topps Al Bemiller 1965 Topps 25 Al Bemiller Buffalo Bills center Syracuse

ex $6

nm $24

exmt
1965 Topps Wray Carlton 1965 Topps 26 Wray Carlton Buffalo Bills fullback Duke

ex $6

nm $24

1965 Topps Tom Day 1965 Topps 27 Tom Day Buffalo Bills defensive end North Carolina A and T Rookie card

ex $7

nm $30


Sponsored Links

Copyright 2003-2014, Nearmint's Vintage Football Cards