Rookie Football Cards

Image Set # Card Title/Players Pro Team Position College Honors Notes Grades available at Nearmint Sports Cards
1957 Topps Paul Hornung 1957 Topps 151 Paul Hornung Green Bay Packers halfback Notre Dame Heisman Trophy 1956, Packers Hall of Fame 1975, College Hall of Fame 1985, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1986 Rookie card

The Packers chose Hornung with the first overall pick in the 1957 NFL draft.
PSA 6, PSA 5
1957 Topps Bill Svoboda 1957 Topps 153 Bill Svoboda New York Giants defensive back Tulane Rookie card ex
1958 Topps Gene Filipski 1958 Topps 1 Gene Filipski New York Giants halfback Villanova, Army Rookie card

Filipski played for the New York Giants in 1956 and 1957, and for the Calgary Stampeders from 1958 to 1961.
PSA 6, exmt
1958 Topps Bill Barnes 1958 Topps 4 Bill Barnes Philadelphia Eagles halfback Wake Forest Rookie card nm oc
1958 Topps Milt Plum 1958 Topps 5 Milt Plum Cleveland Browns quarterback Penn State Rookie card
1958 Topps Pete Brewster 1958 Topps 11 Pete Brewster Cleveland Browns end Purdue Rookie card
1958 Topps Gary Glick 1958 Topps 19 Gary Glick Pittsburgh Steelers defensive back Colorado State Rookie card

The Steelers chose Glick with the first overall pick in the 1956 NFL draft.
1958 Topps Jon Arnett 1958 Topps 20 Jon Arnett Los Angeles Rams halfback USC College Hall of Fame 2001 Rookie card
1958 Topps Carl Brettschneider 1958 Topps 28 Carl Brettschneider Chicago Cardinals linebacker Iowa State Rookie card, error card

Brettschneider's name is misspelled "Brettschnieder."
1958 Topps Vic Zucco 1958 Topps 36 Vic Zucco Chicago Bears defensive back Wayne State Rookie card
1958 Topps Dick Deschaine 1958 Topps 48 Dick Deschaine Green Bay Packers punter Rookie card
1958 Topps Larry Morris 1958 Topps 50 Larry Morris Los Angeles Rams linebacker Georgia Tech College Hall of Fame 1992 Rookie card ex+
1958 Topps Jack McClairen 1958 Topps 51 Jack McClairen Pittsburgh Steelers end Bethune-Cookman Rookie card
1958 Topps Ron Kramer 1958 Topps 58 Ron Kramer Green Bay Packers tight end Michigan Packers Hall of Fame 1975, College Hall of Fame 1978 Rookie card
1958 Topps Jim Brown 1958 Topps 62 Jim Brown Cleveland Browns fullback Syracuse Pro Football Hall of Fame 1971, College Hall of Fame 1995, Browns Ring of Honor 2010 Rookie card PSA 4, PSA 5 mc, PSA 3, PSA 1, PSA 2
1958 Topps Joe Marconi 1958 Topps 63 Joe Marconi Los Angeles Rams fullback West Virginia Rookie card
1958 Topps R.C. Owens 1958 Topps 64 R.C. Owens San Francisco 49ers halfback, end College of Idaho 49ers Hall of Fame 2011 Rookie card, error card

The player pictured is Don Owens, not R.C. Owens. See other football cards that picture the wrong player on my Mistaken Identities page.
1958 Topps Jimmy Carr 1958 Topps 65 Jimmy Carr Chicago Cardinals defensive back Morris Harvey Rookie card

Carr played nine seasons with the NFL's Chicago Cardinals, Philadelphia Eagles, and Washington Redskins. In 1958, the year this card was issued, he played for the Montreal Alouettes in the Canadian Football League.
nm mc
1958 Topps Don McIlhenny 1958 Topps 71 Don McIlhenny Green Bay Packers halfback SMU Rookie card PSA 8.5, vg
1958 Topps Marv Matuszak 1958 Topps 79 Marv Matuszak San Francisco 49ers linebacker Tulsa Rookie card, error card

Last name misspelled "Matuzsak."
nm oc
1958 Topps Earl Putman 1958 Topps 88 Earl Putman Chicago Cardinals center Arizona State Rookie card

Putman played for the Hamilton Tiger-Cats in 1956.
1958 Topps Sonny Jurgensen 1958 Topps 90 Sonny Jurgensen Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Duke Redskins Ring of Fame, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1983, Eagles Honor Roll 1987 Rookie card PSA 8 oc
1958 Topps Paige Cothren 1958 Topps 92 Paige Cothren Los Angeles Rams fullback Mississippi Rookie card

Cothren led the NFL with 38 extra points (in 38 attempts) in 1957.
PSA 6, exmt
1958 Topps Milt Davis 1958 Topps 98 Milt Davis Baltimore Colts halfback Los Angeles City, UCLA Rookie card

In 1957, Davis led the NFL with 10 interceptions, 219 interception return yards, and 2 interceptions returned for touchdowns.
1958 Topps Matt Hazeltine 1958 Topps 100 Matt Hazeltine San Francisco 49ers linebacker California College Hall of Fame 1989 Rookie card nm mc