Rookie Football Cards

To see a large picture of any card (or stamp, sticker, etc.) in the Gallery, click on the small picture or the title.

Picture Set # Card Title/Players Pro Team Position College Honors Notes Est. Retail Value (?) Grades available at nearmintcards.com
1963 Topps Bernie Casey 1963 Topps 137 Bernie Casey San Francisco 49ers end, halfback Bowling Green Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

nm
1963 Topps Ted Connolly 1963 Topps 139 Ted Connolly San Francisco 49ers guard Tulsa Rookie card

Connolly played for the 49ers from 1954 to 1962, but he never appeared on a regular issue football card during that time. He finally appeared on this 1963 Topps card for the 49ers, but by then he had been traded to the Cleveland Browns. 1963 was his last season in the NFL.

ex $2

nm $4

nm+
1963 Topps Dan Colchico 1963 Topps 144 Dan Colchico San Francisco 49ers end San Jose State Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

PSA 8, nm
1963 Topps Charley Johnson 1963 Topps 146 Charley Johnson St. Louis Cardinals quarterback New Mexico State Broncos Ring of Fame 1986 Rookie card, error card

Name misspelled "Charlie."

ex $3

nm $14

exmt
1963 Topps Taz Anderson 1963 Topps 151 Taz Anderson St. Louis Cardinals end Georgia Tech Rookie card

ex $1

nm $4

SGC 88, nm
1963 Topps Ernie McMillan 1963 Topps 152 Ernie McMillan St. Louis Cardinals tackle Illinois Rookie card

ex $2

nm $4

nm
1963 Topps Bill Koman 1963 Topps 154 Bill Koman St. Louis Cardinals linebacker North Carolina Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

PSA 8 oc, nm+
1963 Topps Larry Wilson 1963 Topps 155 Larry Wilson St. Louis Cardinals defensive back Utah Cardinals Ring of Honor 2006, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1978 Rookie card

ex $12

nm $30

PSA 7, SGC 84, exmt
1963 Topps Riley Mattson 1963 Topps 164 Riley Mattson Washington Redskins tackle Oregon Rookie card, short print

ex $3

nm $12

ex
1963 Topps Rod Breedlove 1963 Topps 166 Rod Breedlove Washington Redskins linebacker Maryland Rookie card, short print

ex $4

nm $14

exmt
1963 Topps Claude Crabb 1963 Topps 168 Claude Crabb Washington Redskins halfback Colorado Rookie card, short print, error card

Name misspelled "Claud."

ex $5

nm $22

PSA 6, ex
1964 Philadelphia John Mackey 1964 Philadelphia 3 John Mackey Baltimore Colts tight end Syracuse Pro Football Hall of Fame 1992 Rookie card

ex $20

nm $60

1964 Philadelphia Tom Matte 1964 Philadelphia 6 Tom Matte Baltimore Colts halfback Ohio State Rookie card

ex $3

nm $6

1964 Philadelphia Bennie McRae 1964 Philadelphia 21 Bennie McRae Chicago Bears defensive back, halfback Michigan Rookie card

ex $1

nm $4

PSA 9, SGC 92, SGC 88, nm
1964 Philadelphia Mike Pyle 1964 Philadelphia 24 Mike Pyle Chicago Bears center Yale Rookie card

Pyle played nine seasons in the NFL, all for the Bears.

ex $2

nm $5

SGC 88
1964 Philadelphia Roosevelt Taylor 1964 Philadelphia 25 Roosevelt Taylor Chicago Bears defensive back Grambling Rookie card

ex $1

nm $4

PSA 8.5, PSA 8, SGC 88, nm
1964 Philadelphia John Brewer 1964 Philadelphia 29 John Brewer Cleveland Browns end Mississippi Rookie card

ex $3

nm $6

1964 Philadelphia Gary Collins 1964 Philadelphia 31 Gary Collins Cleveland Browns end Maryland Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

1964 Philadelphia Ernie Green 1964 Philadelphia 35 Ernie Green Cleveland Browns halfback Louisville Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

1964 Philadelphia Charley Scales 1964 Philadelphia 39 Charley Scales Cleveland Browns halfback Indiana Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

1964 Philadelphia Dick Schafrath 1964 Philadelphia 40 Dick Schafrath Cleveland Browns tackle Ohio State Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

vg-ex
1964 Philadelphia Frank Clarke 1964 Philadelphia 44 Frank Clarke Dallas Cowboys halfback Colorado Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

nm+ oc
1964 Philadelphia Lee Folkins 1964 Philadelphia 46 Lee Folkins Dallas Cowboys end Washington Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

nm+ oc
1964 Philadelphia Cornell Green 1964 Philadelphia 47 Cornell Green Dallas Cowboys defensive back Utah State Rookie card

ex $3

nm $5

PSA 9, nm
1964 Philadelphia Pettis Norman 1964 Philadelphia 52 Pettis Norman Dallas Cowboys end Johnson C. Smith Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

1964 Philadelphia Guy Reese 1964 Philadelphia 54 Guy Reese Dallas Cowboys tackle SMU Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

1964 Philadelphia John Gordy 1964 Philadelphia 60 John Gordy Detroit Lions tackle, guard Tennessee Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

SGC 92, exmt
1964 Philadelphia Pat Studstill 1964 Philadelphia 67 Pat Studstill Detroit Lions halfback Houston Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

nm-mt
1964 Philadelphia Wayne Walker 1964 Philadelphia 68 Wayne Walker Detroit Lions linebacker, kicker Idaho Rookie card

ex $3

nm $6

1964 Philadelphia Herb Adderley 1964 Philadelphia 71 Herb Adderley Green Bay Packers defensive back Michigan State Packers Hall of Fame 1981, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1980 Rookie card, error card

Name misspelled "Adderly."

ex $10

nm $30

exmt
1964 Philadelphia Willie Davis 1964 Philadelphia 72 Willie Davis Green Bay Packers defensive end Grambling Packers Hall of Fame 1975, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1981 Rookie card

ex $10

nm $30

nm
1964 Philadelphia Jesse Whittenton 1964 Philadelphia 81 Jesse Whittenton Green Bay Packers defensive back Texas-El Paso Packers Hall of Fame 1976 Rookie card

This was Whittenton's only regular-issue card. He retired after the 1964 season.

ex $2

nm $5

nm
1964 Philadelphia Pervis Atkins 1964 Philadelphia 86 Pervis Atkins Los Angeles Rams halfback New Mexico State College Hall of Fame 2009 Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

PSA 9, nm-mt
1964 Philadelphia Merlin Olsen 1964 Philadelphia 91 Merlin Olsen Los Angeles Rams tackle Utah State College Hall of Fame 1980, Outland Trophy 1961, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1982 Rookie card

ex $10

nm $30

PSA 9
1964 Philadelphia Jack Pardee 1964 Philadelphia 92 Jack Pardee Los Angeles Rams linebacker Texas A and M College Hall of Fame 1986 Rookie card

ex $3

nm $6

1964 Philadelphia Carver Shannon 1964 Philadelphia 94 Carver Shannon Los Angeles Rams halfback Southern Illinois Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

PSA 9, nm+
1964 Philadelphia Grady Alderman 1964 Philadelphia 99 Grady Alderman Minnesota Vikings tackle Detroit Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

nm
1964 Philadelphia Larry Bowie 1964 Philadelphia 100 Larry Bowie Minnesota Vikings guard Purdue Rookie card

Bowie played for the Vikings from 1962 to 1968.

ex $2

nm $6

nm
1964 Philadelphia Bill Brown 1964 Philadelphia 101 Bill Brown Minnesota Vikings running back Illinois Vikings Ring of Honor 2004 Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

nm
1964 Philadelphia Paul Flatley 1964 Philadelphia 102 Paul Flatley Minnesota Vikings end Northwestern Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

1964 Philadelphia Mick Tingelhoff 1964 Philadelphia 110 Mick Tingelhoff Minnesota Vikings center Nebraska Vikings Ring of Honor 2001 Rookie card

Though he was not drafted in the 1962 NFL Draft, Tingelhoff started every game for the Vikings from 1962 to 1978.

ex $3

nm $6

exmt
1964 Philadelphia John LoVetere 1964 Philadelphia 120 John LoVetere New York Giants tackle Compton Community College Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

1964 Philadelphia Dick Lynch 1964 Philadelphia 121 Dick Lynch New York Giants defensive back Notre Dame Giants Ring of Honor 2010 Rookie card

ex $1

nm $5

exmt
1964 Philadelphia Mike Clark 1964 Philadelphia 130 Mike Clark Philadelphia Eagles kicker, end Texas A and M Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

PSA 9, nm+
1964 Philadelphia Irv Cross 1964 Philadelphia 131 Irv Cross Philadelphia Eagles defensive back Northwestern Rookie card

ex $1

nm $5

nm+
1964 Philadelphia Ron Goodwin 1964 Philadelphia 133 Ron Goodwin Philadelphia Eagles halfback Baylor Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

SGC 92, nm-mt
1964 Philadelphia Gary Ballman 1964 Philadelphia 141 Gary Ballman Pittsburgh Steelers halfback Michigan State Rookie card

ex $2

nm $6

1964 Philadelphia Charlie Bradshaw 1964 Philadelphia 142 Charlie Bradshaw Pittsburgh Steelers tackle Baylor Rookie card, error card

Name misspelled "Charley."

ex $1

nm $4

SGC 92, SGC 88, PSA 7, nm
1964 Philadelphia Kermit Alexander 1964 Philadelphia 155 Kermit Alexander San Francisco 49ers defensive back UCLA Rookie card

ex $2

nm $5

1964 Philadelphia Jim Johnson 1964 Philadelphia 161 Jim Johnson San Francisco 49ers defensive back UCLA 49ers Hall of Fame 2009, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1994 Rookie card

ex $15

nm $45


Sponsored Links

Copyright 2003-2014, Nearmint's Vintage Football Cards