Pro Football Hall Of Fame + Rookie Football Cards

Image Set # Card Title/Players Pro Team Position College Honors Notes Grades available at Nearmint Sports Cards
1965 Topps Willie Brown 1965 Topps 46 Willie Brown Denver Broncos defensive back Grambling Pro Football Hall of Fame 1984 Rookie card

Brown was not drafted by any professional team. The Houston Oilers signed him but cut him during training camp in 1963. The Broncos then signed him, and by mid-season he was in their starting lineup.
1965 Topps Joe Namath 1965 Topps 122 Joe Namath New York Jets quarterback Alabama Pro Football Hall of Fame 1985, Jets Ring of Honor 2010 Rookie card
1965 Topps Fred Biletnikoff 1965 Topps 133 Fred Biletnikoff Oakland Raiders end Florida State Pro Football Hall of Fame 1988, College Hall of Fame 1991 Rookie card
1966 Philadelphia Dick Butkus 1966 Philadelphia 31 Dick Butkus Chicago Bears linebacker Illinois Pro Football Hall of Fame 1979, College Hall of Fame 1983 Rookie card

Butkus won the Big Ten's MVP award, the Chicago Tribune Silver Football, in 1963.
PSA 4, PSA 2.5
1966 Philadelphia Gale Sayers 1966 Philadelphia 38 Gale Sayers Chicago Bears halfback Kansas College Hall of Fame 1977, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1977 Rookie card, double print PSA 8 mk, PSA 5, PSA 4, PSA 4 mk, PSA 3, PSA 2
1966 Philadelphia Gene Hickerson 1966 Philadelphia 45 Gene Hickerson Cleveland Browns guard Mississippi Pro Football Hall of Fame 2007, Browns Ring of Honor 2010 Rookie card, double print ex
1966 Philadelphia Bob Hayes 1966 Philadelphia 58 Bob Hayes Dallas Cowboys wide receiver Florida A and M Cowboys Ring of Honor 2001, Pro Football Hall of Fame 2009 Rookie card
1966 Philadelphia Bob Brown 1966 Philadelphia 134 Bob Brown Philadelphia Eagles tackle Nebraska College Hall of Fame 1993, Eagles Honor Roll 2004, Pro Football Hall of Fame 2004 Rookie card, double print
1967 Philadelphia Leroy Kelly 1967 Philadelphia 43 Leroy Kelly Cleveland Browns running back Morgan State Pro Football Hall of Fame 1994, Browns Ring of Honor 2010 Rookie card
1967 Philadelphia Dave Robinson 1967 Philadelphia 80 Dave Robinson Green Bay Packers linebacker Penn State Packers Hall of Fame 1982, College Hall of Fame 1997, Pro Football Hall of Fame 2013 Rookie card, double print exmt
1967 Philadelphia Jackie Smith 1967 Philadelphia 165 Jackie Smith St. Louis Cardinals tight end, kicker Northwestern Louisiana Pro Football Hall of Fame 1994 Rookie card ex
1967 Philadelphia Dave Wilcox 1967 Philadelphia 178 Dave Wilcox San Francisco 49ers linebacker Oregon Pro Football Hall of Fame 2000, 49ers Hall of Fame 2009 Rookie card ex
1967 Philadelphia Chris Hanburger 1967 Philadelphia 183 Chris Hanburger Washington Redskins linebacker North Carolina Redskins Ring of Fame, Pro Football Hall of Fame 2011 Rookie card PSA 6, PSA 5, ex, PSA 4.5, PSA 7
1968 Topps Floyd Little 1968 Topps 173 Floyd Little Denver Broncos running back Syracuse College Hall of Fame 1983, Broncos Ring of Fame 1984, Pro Football Hall of Fame 2010 Rookie card PSA 8, PSA 7
1968 Topps Bob Griese 1968 Topps 196 Bob Griese Miami Dolphins quarterback Purdue College Hall of Fame 1984, Dolphins Honor Roll 1990, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1990 Rookie card

Griese placed eighth in voting for the Heisman Trophy in 1965, and second in 1966. See the Gallery's page of football cards of Heisman Trophy candidates.
PSA 7
1969 Topps Larry Csonka 1969 Topps 120 Larry Csonka Miami Dolphins fullback Syracuse Pro Football Hall of Fame 1987, College Hall of Fame 1989, Dolphins Honor Roll 1990 Rookie card PSA 7, ex
1970 Topps Jan Stenerud 1970 Topps 25 Jan Stenerud Kansas City Chiefs kicker Montana State Packers Hall of Fame 1991, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1991, Chiefs Hall of Fame 1992 Rookie card
1970 Topps Elvin Bethea 1970 Topps 43 Elvin Bethea Houston Oilers defensive end North Carolina A and T Pro Football Hall of Fame 2003 Rookie card PSA 8
1970 Topps Alan Page 1970 Topps 59 Alan Page Minnesota Vikings defensive tackle Notre Dame Pro Football Hall of Fame 1988, College Hall of Fame 1993, Vikings Ring of Honor 1998 Rookie card
1970 Topps Lem Barney 1970 Topps 75 Lem Barney Detroit Lions defensive back Jackson State Pro Football Hall of Fame 1992 Rookie card
1970 Topps O.J. Simpson 1970 Topps 90 O.J. Simpson Buffalo Bills running back USC, City College of San Francisco Heisman Trophy 1968, Bills Wall of Fame 1980, College Hall of Fame 1983, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1985 Rookie card
1970 Topps Tom Mack 1970 Topps 151 Tom Mack Los Angeles Rams guard Michigan Pro Football Hall of Fame 1999 Rookie card
1970 Topps Claude Humphrey 1970 Topps 156 Claude Humphrey Atlanta Falcons defensive end Tennessee State Falcons Ring of Honor 2008, Pro Football Hall of Fame 2014 Rookie card
1971 Topps Ken Houston 1971 Topps 113 Ken Houston Houston Oilers defensive back Prairie View Redskins Ring of Fame, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1986 Rookie card

Houston set an NFL record by returning four interceptions for touchdowns in 1971. Jim Kearney and Eric Allen have since tied that record.
PSA 8 oc
1971 Topps Willie Lanier 1971 Topps 114 Willie Lanier Kansas City Chiefs linebacker Morgan State Chiefs Hall of Fame 1985, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1986, College Hall of Fame 2000 Rookie card