College Hall Of Fame Football Cards
To see a large picture of any card (or stamp, sticker, etc.) in the Gallery, click on the small picture or the title. To estimate a card's value, click the Recent Sales link in the eBay Searches column and look for cards in the same condition as yours.
| Picture | Set | # | Card | Pro Team | Position | College | Honors | Notes | Est. NM Value (?) | eBay Searches |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
1957 Topps | 46 | Elroy Hirsch | Los Angeles Rams | end, halfback | Wisconsin, Michigan | College Hall of Fame 1974, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1968 | $22 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
|
1957 Topps | 47 | Don Heinrich | New York Giants | quarterback, coach | Washington | College Hall of Fame 1987 | Heinrich placed ninth in voting for the 1952 Heisman Trophy. See my page of football cards of Heisman candidates. | $8 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
1957 Topps | 49 | Chuck Bednarik | Philadelphia Eagles | center, defensive tackle | Pennsylvania | College Hall of Fame 1969, Eagles Honor Roll 1987, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1967 | $22 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
|
1957 Topps | 53 | Alan Ameche | Baltimore Colts | fullback | Wisconsin | College Hall of Fame 1975, Heisman Trophy 1954 | $12 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
|
1957 Topps | 59 | Kyle Rote | New York Giants | end | SMU | College Hall of Fame 1964 | $18 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
|
1957 Topps | 73 | Bob Pellegrini | Philadelphia Eagles | linebacker | Maryland | College Hall of Fame 1996 | Pellegrini did not play in 1957. According to his College Football Hall of Fame page, he served in the Army that year. | $13 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
1957 Topps | 79 | J.C. Caroline | Chicago Bears | defensive back | Illinois | College Hall of Fame 1980 | Rookie card Caroline played for the Toronto Argonauts and Montreal Alouettes in 1955, then joined the Bears in 1956. He played for the Bears until 1965. |
$9 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
1957 Topps | 80 | Howard Cassady | Detroit Lions | halfback | Ohio State | College Hall of Fame 1979, Heisman Trophy 1955 | Rookie card | $11 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
1957 Topps | 88 | Frank Gifford | New York Giants | halfback | USC | College Hall of Fame 1975, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1977 | $30 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
|
1957 Topps | 89 | Steve Meilinger | Washington Redskins | end | Kentucky | College Hall of Fame 2013 | Meilinger placed tenth in voting for the 1953 Heisman Trophy. See my page of football cards of Heisman candidates. | $20 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
1957 Topps | 95 | Hugh McElhenny | San Francisco 49ers | halfback | Washington | 49ers Hall of Fame 2009, College Hall of Fame 1981, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1970 | $24 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
|
1957 Topps | 96 | Stan Jones | Chicago Bears | guard | Maryland | College Hall of Fame 2000, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1991 | $28 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
|
1957 Topps | 108 | Bud McFadin | Los Angeles Rams | defensive tackle | Texas | College Hall of Fame 1983 | Rookie card | $24 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
1957 Topps | 109 | Charley Conerly | New York Giants | quarterback | Mississippi | Giants Ring of Honor 2010, College Hall of Fame 1966 | $21 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
|
1957 Topps | 118 | Leon Hart | Detroit Lions | fullback | Notre Dame | College Hall of Fame 1973, Heisman Trophy 1949 | $45 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
|
1957 Topps | 124 | Tommy McDonald | Philadelphia Eagles | end, halfback | Oklahoma | College Hall of Fame 1985, Eagles Honor Roll 1988, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1998 | Rookie card | $103 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
1957 Topps | 125 | Jerry Tubbs | Chicago Cardinals | linebacker | Oklahoma | College Hall of Fame 1996 | Rookie card Tubbs spent ten seasons in the NFL, playing for the Chicago Cardinals, San Francisco 49ers, and Dallas Cowboys. |
$13 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
1957 Topps | 126 | Jack Scarbath | Pittsburgh Steelers | quarterback | Maryland | College Hall of Fame 1983 | $23 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
|
1957 Topps | 144 | Ken MacAfee | New York Giants | end | Alabama | College Hall of Fame 1999 | MacAfee's son, also named Ken, played tight end for two seasons with the San Francisco 49ers. | $29 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
|
1957 Topps | 151 | Paul Hornung | Green Bay Packers | halfback | Notre Dame | College Hall of Fame 1985, Heisman Trophy 1956, Packers Hall of Fame 1975, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1986 | Rookie card | $375 | Current Listings Recent Sales |
 | Listing Title | Listing Type | Price | Time Left |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 | BOB JOHNSON - Tennessee VOLS Autograph AUTO College FB Hall of Fame 1989 | Auction | 0.99 | 5 days 22 hrs |
 | Charles Haley SF 49ers College Hall Of Fame 1987 Topps Super Rookie Card #125 | Auction | 10.00 | 6 days 2 hrs |
Copyright 2003-2013, Nearmint's Vintage Football Cards
eBay and the eBay Logo are trademarks of eBay Inc.