Yale Alumni Football Cards

To see a large picture of any card (or stamp, sticker, etc.) in the Gallery, click on the small picture or the title.

Picture Set # Card Title/Players Pro Team Position College Honors Notes Est. Retail Value (?) Grades available at nearmintcards.com
1888 Goodwin Champions Henry Beecher 1888 Goodwin Champions 1 Henry Beecher Yale The first football card

poor $1000

vg $2500

ex $4000

1894 Mayo Cut Plug George Adee 1894 Mayo Cut Plug 2 George Adee Yale Adee is a member of the International Tennis Hall of Fame.

poor $150

vg $375

ex $900

1894 Mayo Cut Plug Richard Armstrong 1894 Mayo Cut Plug 3 Richard Armstrong Yale Armstrong was captain of the 1895 Yale crew.

poor $150

vg $375

ex $900

1894 Mayo Cut Plug Anson Beard 1894 Mayo Cut Plug 6 Anson Beard Yale

poor $150

vg $375

ex $900

1894 Mayo Cut Plug Frank Butterworth 1894 Mayo Cut Plug 10 Frank Butterworth Yale

poor $150

vg $375

ex $900

1894 Mayo Cut Plug John Greenway 1894 Mayo Cut Plug 16 John Greenway Yale

poor $150

vg $375

ex $900

1894 Mayo Cut Plug William Hickok 1894 Mayo Cut Plug 17 William Hickok guard Yale College Hall of Fame 1971

poor $150

vg $375

ex $900

1894 Mayo Cut Plug Frank Hinkey 1894 Mayo Cut Plug 18 Frank Hinkey end Yale College Hall of Fame 1951

poor $150

vg $375

ex $900

1894 Mayo Cut Plug Jim McCrea 1894 Mayo Cut Plug 23 Jim McCrea Yale

poor $150

vg $375

ex $900

1894 Mayo Cut Plug Fred Murphy 1894 Mayo Cut Plug 25 Fred Murphy Yale

poor $150

vg $375

ex $900

1894 Mayo Cut Plug Phillip Stillman 1894 Mayo Cut Plug 28 Phillip Stillman Yale

poor $150

vg $375

ex $900

1894 Mayo Cut Plug Brinck Thorne 1894 Mayo Cut Plug 30 Brinck Thorne halfback Yale College Hall of Fame 1970

poor $150

vg $375

ex $900

1948 Bowman Frank Barzilauskas 1948 Bowman 92 Frank Barzilauskas Boston Yanks guard Holy Cross, Yale Rookie card

Barzilauskas's nephew, Carl Barzilauskas, played for the New York Jets and Green Bay Packers.

ex $12

nm $70

SGC 88, PSA 6
1948 Leaf Levi Jackson 1948 Leaf 5 Levi Jackson halfback Yale Rookie card

vg $10

ex $25

nm $125

1948 Topps Magic Photos Yale vs. Columbia 1948 Topps Magic Photos 4R Yale vs. Columbia Yale, Columbia
1950 Topps Felt Backs Levi Jackson 1950 Topps Felt Backs 38 Levi Jackson halfback Yale

nm $132

1951 Bowman John Prchlik 1951 Bowman 100 John Prchlik Detroit Lions tackle, defensive tackle Yale

ex $9

nm $34

1954 Quaker Sports Oddities Amos Alonzo Stagg 1954 Quaker Sports Oddities 7 Amos Alonzo Stagg coach Yale College Hall of Fame 1951

nm $5

nm-mt $10

mint $20

1955 Topps All-American Pudge Heffelfinger 1955 Topps All-American 18 Pudge Heffelfinger guard Yale College Hall of Fame 1951 Rookie card

vg $5

ex $10

nm $30

PSA 7, PSA 5.5, exmt
1955 Topps All-American Larry Kelley 1955 Topps All-American 26 Larry Kelley end Yale College Hall of Fame 1969, Heisman Trophy 1936 Rookie card

vg $12

ex $24

nm $55

PSA 9, nm
1955 Topps All-American Amos Alonzo Stagg 1955 Topps All-American 38 Amos Alonzo Stagg coach Yale College Hall of Fame 1951 Rookie card

vg $15

ex $30

nm $75

nm-mt oc
1955 Topps All-American Ted Coy 1955 Topps All-American 83 Ted Coy fullback Yale College Hall of Fame 1951

vg $5

ex $10

nm $32

GAI 8, exmt+
1955 Topps All-American Albie Booth 1955 Topps All-American 86 Albie Booth quarterback Yale College Hall of Fame 1966

vg $5

ex $10

nm $30

ex
1960 Fleer College Pennant Decals Alabama - Yale 1960 Fleer College Pennant Decals 1 Alabama - Yale Alabama, Yale
1960 Topps Metallic Stickers Yale Bulldogs 1960 Topps Metallic Stickers 33 Yale Bulldogs Yale
1961 Nu-Card Alex Kroll 1961 Nu-Card 123 Alex Kroll tackle, center Rutgers, Yale College Hall of Fame 1997 Kroll played for the New York Titans.

nm $3

mint $8

1963 Fleer Alex Kroll 1963 Fleer 16 Alex Kroll New York Jets tackle, center Rutgers, Yale College Hall of Fame 1997 Rookie card

ex $4

nm $7

1964 Philadelphia Mike Pyle 1964 Philadelphia 24 Mike Pyle Chicago Bears center Yale Rookie card

Pyle played nine seasons in the NFL, all for the Bears.

ex $2

nm $5

SGC 88
1964 Wheaties Stamps Mike Pyle 1964 Wheaties Stamps 54 Mike Pyle Chicago Bears center Yale Pyle's brother Palmer also played in the NFL.
1965 Philadelphia Mike Pyle 1965 Philadelphia 24 Mike Pyle Chicago Bears center Yale

ex $3

nm $7

1966 Philadelphia Mike Pyle 1966 Philadelphia 37 Mike Pyle Chicago Bears center Yale Double print

ex $3

nm $6

SGC 92, PSA 8, nm
1966 Philadelphia Giants Play 1966 Philadelphia 130 Giants Play Double print

ex $3

nm $6

SGC 96, PSA 9
Chuck Mercein New York Giants running back Yale
1967 Philadelphia Mike Pyle 1967 Philadelphia 34 Mike Pyle Chicago Bears center Yale Double print

ex $2

nm $4

PSA 8, ex
1969 Glendale Stamps Mike Pyle 1969 Glendale Stamps 57 Mike Pyle Chicago Bears center Yale
1970 Kelloggs Calvin Hill 1970 Kelloggs 49 Calvin Hill Dallas Cowboys running back Yale

nm $3

nm-mt
1970 Topps Mike Pyle 1970 Topps 37 Mike Pyle Chicago Bears center Yale

nm $3

PSA 9
1970 Topps Calvin Hill 1970 Topps 260B Calvin Hill Dallas Cowboys running back Yale Rookie card

Variation with name in black.

nm $4

1970 Topps Calvin Hill 1970 Topps 260R Calvin Hill Dallas Cowboys running back Yale Rookie card

Variation with name in red.

nm $3

1970 Topps Super Calvin Hill 1970 Topps Super 28 Calvin Hill Dallas Cowboys running back Yale

nm $6

1971 Topps Calvin Hill 1971 Topps 217 Calvin Hill Dallas Cowboys running back Yale

nm $5

1972 Topps Calvin Hill Pro Action 1972 Topps 129 Calvin Hill Pro Action

nm $4

Calvin Hill Dallas Cowboys running back Yale
1972 Topps Calvin Hill 1972 Topps 224 Calvin Hill Dallas Cowboys running back Yale

nm $4

1973 Topps Calvin Hill 1973 Topps 35 Calvin Hill Dallas Cowboys running back Yale

nm $4

nm-mt $8

1974 Parker Brothers Calvin Hill 1974 Parker Brothers 95 Calvin Hill Dallas Cowboys running back Yale
1974 Topps Calvin Hill 1974 Topps 95 Calvin Hill Dallas Cowboys running back Yale
1974 Topps Brian Dowling 1974 Topps 357 Brian Dowling New England Patriots quarterback Yale Rookie card

Dowling placed ninth in voting for the Heisman Trophy in 1968. See my page of football cards of Heisman Trophy candidates.
1976 Topps Calvin Hill 1976 Topps 131 Calvin Hill Washington Redskins running back Yale Hill's son, Grant Hill is a seven-time NBA All-Star and the oldest active player in the league.
1977 Topps 429 Calvin Hill Washington Redskins running back Yale
1978 Topps Calvin Hill 1978 Topps 71 Calvin Hill Washington Redskins running back Yale
1978 Topps Gary Fencik 1978 Topps 497 Gary Fencik Chicago Bears defensive back Yale Rookie card

Sponsored Links

Copyright 2003-2014, Nearmint's Vintage Football Cards