| Player | # | Pro Team | Position | College | Hometown | Honors |
| Erich Barnes | 40 | Cleveland Browns | defensive back |
Purdue |
Elkhart, IN |
|
| Walter Beach | 49 | Cleveland Browns | halfback |
Central Michigan |
|
|
| John Brewer | 83 | Cleveland Browns | end |
Mississippi |
|
|
| John Brown | 70 | Cleveland Browns | tackle |
Syracuse |
Camden, NJ |
|
| Monte Clark | 73 | Cleveland Browns | tackle, defensive tackle |
USC |
Fillmore, CA |
|
| Gary Collins | 86 | Cleveland Browns | end |
Maryland |
Williamstown, PA |
|
| Vince Costello | 50 | Cleveland Browns | linebacker |
Ohio |
Magnolia, OH |
|
| Ross Fichtner | 20 | Cleveland Browns | defensive back |
Purdue |
|
|
| Galen Fiss | 35 | Cleveland Browns | linebacker |
Kansas |
Johnson, KS |
|
| Bobby Franklin | 22 | Cleveland Browns | defensive back |
Mississippi |
Clarksdale, MS |
|
| Bill Glass | 80 | Cleveland Browns | defensive end |
Baylor |
Corpus Christi, TX |
College Hall of Fame 1985 |
| Ernie Green | 48 | Cleveland Browns | halfback |
Louisville |
|
|
| Lou Groza | 76 | Cleveland Browns | tackle, kicker |
Ohio State |
|
Browns Ring of Honor 2010, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1974 |
| Charlie Harraway | 31 | Cleveland Browns | running back |
San Jose State |
|
|
| Gene Hickerson | 66 | Cleveland Browns | guard |
Mississippi |
|
Browns Ring of Honor 2010, Pro Football Hall of Fame 2007 |
| Jim Houston | 82 | Cleveland Browns | linebacker, defensive end |
Ohio State |
Massillon, OH |
College Hall of Fame 2005 |
| Mike Howell | 34 | Cleveland Browns | defensive back |
Grambling |
|
|
| Tom Hutchinson | 87 | Cleveland Browns | end |
Kentucky |
|
|
| Joe Bob Isbell | 61 | Cleveland Browns | guard |
Houston |
Gorman, TX |
|
| Walter Johnson | 71 | Cleveland Browns | defensive tackle |
California State - LA |
|
|
| Jim Kanicki | 69 | Cleveland Browns | defensive tackle |
Michigan State |
|
|
| Ernie Kellerman | 24 | Cleveland Browns | defensive back |
Miami Ohio |
|
|
| Leroy Kelly | 44 | Cleveland Browns | running back |
Morgan State |
Philadelphia, PA |
Browns Ring of Honor 2010, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1994 |
| Gary Lane | 15 | Cleveland Browns | quarterback |
Missouri |
Alton, IL |
|
| Dale Lindsey | 51 | Cleveland Browns | linebacker |
Kentucky, Western Kentucky |
Bowling Green, KY |
|
| Clifton McNeil | 85 | Cleveland Browns | wide receiver |
Grambling |
|
|
| Dick Modzelewski | 74 | Cleveland Browns | defensive tackle |
Maryland |
Brackenridge, PA |
College Hall of Fame 1993, Outland Trophy 1952 |
| Milt Morin | 89 | Cleveland Browns | tight end |
Massachusetts |
Fitchburg, MA |
College Hall of Fame 2010 |
| John Morrow | 56 | Cleveland Browns | center |
Michigan |
|
|
| Jim Ninowski | 11 | Cleveland Browns | quarterback |
Michigan State |
Detroit, MI |
|
| Frank Parker | 78 | Cleveland Browns | defensive tackle |
Oklahoma State |
Broken Bow, OK |
|
| Bernie Parrish | 30 | Cleveland Browns | defensive back |
Florida |
|
|
| Walter Roberts | 27 | Cleveland Browns | wide receiver |
Pacific |
|
|
| Frank Ryan | 13 | Cleveland Browns | quarterback |
Rice |
Fort Worth, TX |
|
| Dick Schafrath | 77 | Cleveland Browns | tackle |
Ohio State |
|
|
| Randy Schultz | 33 | Cleveland Browns | running back |
Northern Iowa |
Iowa Falls, IA |
|
| Ralph Smith | 41 | Cleveland Browns | tight end |
Mississippi |
Brookhaven, MS |
|
| Paul Warfield | 42 | Cleveland Browns | wide receiver |
Ohio State |
Warren, OH |
Browns Ring of Honor 2010, Dolphins Honor Roll 1990, Pro Football Hall of Fame 1983 |
| Paul Wiggin | 84 | Cleveland Browns | defensive end |
Stanford |
Manteca, CA |
College Hall of Fame 2005 |
| Sid Williams | 67 | Cleveland Browns | linebacker |
Southern |
Shreveport, LA |
|
| John Wooten | 60 | Cleveland Browns | guard |
Colorado |
Clarksville, TX |
College Hall of Fame 2012 |
